Are either of these fabrications? And if not, which of the two are the best preserved?

[PaleoBlue]

Hello all, I am trying to decide between two fossils for my collection. Are these two fossils both authentic? And if so, which would you say looks better?

[Ludwigia]

They both look real but the choice is up to you.

[Fossildude19]

First photo is not good enough to make a determination as to which looks better.

 

Second one looks better in the current pictures, but the first one doesn't show the whole fossil from above.

 

Impossible to determine with these photos. 

[PaleoBlue]

5 hours ago, Fossildude19 said:

First photo is not good enough to make a determination as to which looks better.

 

Second one looks better in the current pictures, but the first one doesn't show the whole fossil from above.

 

Impossible to determine with these photos. 

Yeah, i wish there were better photos but sadly the only other one was just a photo of it flipped over. I think I will go for the second one. It’s larger, much cheaper, and in my opinion it’s easier to tell what parts are what, especially for those who may not be as well versed in fossils and anatomy. Thank you so much for the reply!