Unknown orthocone from Ithaca, New York

[Nautiloid]

Last year while on a fishing trip in Ithaca, NY I found this as well as some brachiopods in a small outcrop of shale along a stream. I’m pretty sure it’s Devonian in age but I haven’t been able to identify the species. 

[connorp]

I won't be able to help with the ID, but I'm guessing those that can will need some closer up pictures to make a determination.

[Fossildude19]

Try taking your photos in daylight, on a non-reflective surface.   

[Nautiloid]

@Fossildude19 I’ll take some better pics tomorrow. 

[Nautiloid]

@Fossildude19 hopefully these pics are more detailed. I tried taking them in better lighting this time.