Jump to content

Looking to identify this Early-Devonian (Helderberg) Coral


FossilRPalace

Recommended Posts

Hello everyone, I've been working on extracting this piece of coral from the Rock Cut Quarry, located in Syracuse, New York. The part of the quarry wall this piece came out of is part of the Helderberg Group, sitting below the Onondaga Formation. I was looking forward to see if anyone had some input on identifying the species of coral. I believe its  Favosites sphaericus.

 

mSX5TUqeI5EFW7k9hUKwuhjH8go_391kfgKnNoJaO3MCisVXfevbS_DF13Ehk2t4FYPLRR_YC-hFQd3hGSZ4kRsH-QouUTFsLAtQjOsNQfSL7WlSzeBpLkUBjTAP7mazGDgvEG6s0ciJwsqFgKS0oJQuRmxVDjwZwobkRxStss-YzfRb0HPW9IoznFew1U0NGCEAdPvV8Z7eWA7LQ_gZPmy_zmHU11J-r4WhgQQd2Fs7XFlH1CyTPFgO8QizU0obFDOsKa3v9LpQxoO7_r67DAekwtYI1E-srZrNICjKOOSAz0qv6klNx_b26VHAoIpY6jl1ITtIiFWOQJm0QXh01vkpBGtIDt-PFTEFXF2vEwfzNvj-5r193th7Vu9syjLdBAauFEYacuixxSnemdT7Q7VpAriZWMttdKtKQRugs99gMsemD9o40voSbnZ6zgROHwqTqi6lPpC94RAkj9i2jQuHz3gtiyk78c-RIn7Hga8wgVX8Dixe2kI7C34w_ItC85WX8tmSCtxeIKSsk1f_unQgAy6TAIBmSm5lz-2_vve7PBqSwy5VQ7fetBuHjLfVlHa95rpvm0c6TWC1Tz6qMKg9IZHj6cvfyLTtjU3OZtAcoOY3xVmzJt95qOL-CM5ekAeX9iZlqV1key2B8DXWtxuQu8nu6zdqL9kdl29XGcB3wtTZkavT4SFVGpMtp75rHn3luRrT9oMBLodZqXO8StIezg=w834-h625-no?authuser=0 zuMETr5Zc6LxESDqVS2InjuSWoQq0C7s6byvO9NcAWoL2gbBz0ev00ndfThtqjwULlW4yXTRXLzcue2rx-KxZsEcJ_11ghp71yrUr496scow-v3fkTuIRUr1El6ItYhEKqxcTxSHeXNkei_ZBvf6omalcA9nBnVzqczxmDBNpVisc2L6hdFY1mFFcMBqj9kjlza-wmSfjB83tqtE7mbmIQgsWty037W1kRtpGpboEQQhgKnDJp-cZuVmHw13DS8eQJtxqlT_lLSKrv0hWp1Kbfo5JLAWGJtlq5ccXEPds2v8afYFuY3bSsjaIKxY2QW83t5M4Q5qhxSVAXXztPv6TPFEoqDqetimSsSOa__-iGZUaj7Ot37QP4LImIpXZ8nzAnLut0nZa2FYP8iBk9scrH_TtNkFEh8uaLV9nMzOpuGGpydE2LEEsu1KAPupPYhxnPpnJCf8k7n9xxfAv7wJk96Ig9w2VU4oOITXDPIvpaQTDRHrpeRWJ9PmXM1lEtQuyudu5tLPKbk-U_oom2XseWUUOTt_ZIt1Aq8wVSrNqtGSg6aZYBTqbMyazSz2Nw5zX9To8ZqEJNpk5vJDMO3RD37QKwIbbOhvqkgaA900p632YGSZxUslrfhBoOajhORHJ8sDxt5ercQROSo_2bfQlVM7zl7wMOgS2Ua60vpdUQnSLB2s9HGmDdyj48UNdH6vFh5jAJ8t1jC0hvBZoPkOX86wfg=w834-h625-no?authuser=0

 

Cross-section: 

bduMDNUKy4p-fic53RbbjvY9j-tiFfObL6rzXb1tx1XKbxfq-m7YNABtjFO-aO7ZV6gZSQ13Kt2C1_WXL8F2Gm0FLsWo3oz5bVyz-FViyIzkgV0q0GA2kN4_FKwROGtVotxF0F0AqL5t66xYp0cS_4G4j8EFzIZSz4MY9S1KgytANdfjQ3eSpFxsocJ4LL6IeFguESZfTMcFH0n-a23Pj4V1tEJ1vazA8hUeFWbAM0B3M6hWHwkDlPawRtj84Nwzc4H_7ub_FtMWLIQORQQtOMbOiS1vmG_xo2ZLtCgBydSTbaTpkrwAp5zUn70Ewn4pvtTu6IjpyuN2b6u8LiX_4XHYwiL6LifknLE4dH_b5wj4QWSmhUg6UJ3WQWcMNzolNAfcxkzGpiGz1GUglBBBtsWoS6ZDGL_rHELj7Dw4R37yaXZ-EhDiBEFlYKMQIX_XVymbm46IpVjZU_5v9DQy4gcfV2sAju6P2F30ARIoc6xHwVxZ9t63svL5ow9WkMI-0CcLX6vKMdBmafueQGRGImRhT7CQ4lW-YM9H_DIXidqLM0U_oDupJiRCEssVFh5lI5azWxgKEsKyZIRkdBOirGlMCu1Inp3JzLjLmonue9GrXzNHIFvLlAPLto8ZcHiF6T464wiWuUMsj1luZZ_NJ-8fglHpF8kIqAUEC_V8IVmFHbhVok_KSrUBXoNzVbG7UD0YURCkCo-SNKDRgM60UsBnkw=w469-h625-no?authuser=0

 

Top close-ups:

JbmQ1_zdfGW4hRGxOnY9GaEPGpmgq-niKuGV8ozlPlST-tYXbn6Grdzqf9Af0eFqG0FsM52L-3NhMU0WxeGMu_Ydry1SpXpuebrmbM0QghuSrUHk7SsfHF8-eUwxWI73KAuefKPW3UTKLfXI_IisCRzpDEKZ1RpNgI9-e8gNdBprzO5OnyS96LsR8NOVk6L6Cog8WCqIatPziZ2L4Ci-t7_HzCQcJcIE9JentUfystldV-VqlNXWWO-tBBdBq9ySkDkxNRcvuwp5GnOG2bdg_lwbx1fysVCj1BD_0532R6LPokbRQxzLkLPsIqPCJRe2-ZdxOrJorRivM8NvZazl6CF3mhn6whgpx5s3C9CYCKvqDmrYnOXkPVBeHgiKQgq__SKjTKXQiHLB5hiVtDmGupR6FZKxZBr4ndGg0f5lzMAz5mWF77VFjxNHcWv80AFEublzzIZWNM1FeSNVNw-I54lHmFqwdOSjpZ7y8LYMnRPhAoADkz5iTIC2REgxp2X1ejJX8NPQYJwPWHp7Mhgjy6T5Je52Z-EU0__gpyqq4Ie6QXPMKpv_av8N23XI7GW4Sq7Mzs5GtLiS8BW2bMfGYBvT6ILfjBwqR-0OUnmywbu3Jet7_hWaMcImi25x55rvnQR7F41aHKCEfFhpkwSDDB3EGDQewySNYApDVJM3sC6F4bkEslE4cvmvW3zClKAIGF3tm-ATVQU4qrLdUGOXnHtp_Q=w834-h625-no?authuser=0PEew207OBQNa9aAJm3I4zEpYhsRdVgij6BG-_Z9yrbUtINVv9j4_NzdXS0uNHG7rDKfQM6b1lsQdOAlAKtNknkToyDJW6lllKstaoasetQMWM_plIj1GqarCR1gotjCW796UoyKTXsNSaPWjotRrGe8pRSwr8dr_QgrvDD-1dJexRhxd3FMNqfqm1u0R9SzIxOY_Fb9JhkqA-BRPA0lRLtQvoZQXNRWkvnx-fODPu4lF3E3XgavoR2q9njJVYyWakE540-9SfJ9H6RVRaYhKlLXaaEC0QFvz7js1mqyiD8lLBCfsNRaJEh5ge76G_JO-aVjJdeEjPS4xYko4gxmTTXVhvgYFZJ2j4I-TS7QKdcrfgy5ihziauchHcRPNndQeO0wm74sqTnBnUp3upmizIA_HTU4HQycJVU_gZE4jZc-EDBhbNS7aTHJ8B7izaEXW768FMcsBsaWW0DobUiHHf1llMfMEFbnFWlaxgMw5CfqaQZ0Y1vz_5iYFR2W1xu5qjUD_sGoH_hjJkTDgc6IfjCSxZjBU_x0XG7OsFzrMpQmzLNrZlak5o2x5JFrfZ_m4JA3bUr5FJJbBmla2UYmvrEVCR5BOqE4qd3EPsKxQ12oAQVKL9-bd6SB4mQlkO5wFcIzx5UUlAIn4QWMdUgRV4FedoOyDeTOxbTz8MdumdHa6qbDGM0fYnx8jJtNJnPHeAn0hUFW5yARe6JthbzgWQi4qpA=w834-h625-no?authuser=0

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Favosites helderbergiae Hall? Maybe.

  • I Agree 1

    Tim    -  VETERAN SHALE SPLITTER

   MOTM.png.61350469b02f439fd4d5d77c2c69da85.png      PaleoPartner.png.30c01982e09b0cc0b7d9d6a7a21f56c6.png.a600039856933851eeea617ca3f2d15f.png     Postmaster1.jpg.900efa599049929531fa81981f028e24.jpg    VFOTM.png.f1b09c78bf88298b009b0da14ef44cf0.png  VFOTM  --- APRIL - 2015  

__________________________________________________
"In every walk with nature one receives far more than he seeks."

John Muir ~ ~ ~ ~   ><))))( *>  About Me      

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you for the quick reply, it could be Favosites helderbergiae Hall. My Field Guide to Devonian Fossils of NY by Karl A. Wilson shows a cross-section of Favosites helderbergiae which appears to have little chambers/segments. I find it a bit hard to see a similar structure in this piece (could just be my inexperience). 

cvbCro1UTMN6ibY7Nko9nE3yE8EDa3f6SeeOZI2kmiImID53QvOx-fa3hh9P_GJYySA95WLuaejh8D5I8VLFasSX4ikPamtxFQPvCAZqwlcTQd2sYAqSNIzhJTby9sHXHZuMUfXrefVJeLmHDWdBamAUAPIW9aHSP0TdvWzPZ2qNJ8UeCrJOEuFMPspLK0C5_OoBmp6ybcjQwM1eHJFSnGA-Y06uDWUfFrNfVDbHw0G5TYa20oXKpXLX1Y8oEhb3_LgiF52356GH3K0moeztOeTcGCvcjmVOSQcuMSRovkuLJAGc-VYEsu9Jc0avbMpaGI3TTQVvs_nJrHD0MN8uCJTNBxQkL71qrL0aEgRVGymZB_xbqrjj3bzmkKQC771kp3Is01Y9ryniScbILXPbpza4RKe4oAuv2M-ILgvmYty3kmMv3p0D1zG0Ot-g2OdnJXZQMoElcl4DZXtNt7BlIMrUXNsKdVQrjllvt4wK9ePvBXZXmr3xCEP4U71YvfoHeTOVTEw7HksjXdznJ8jNmEdPZ8HL6W9IsGnnKVjNRgryCJM11bs4nlRccJVGRSxzVkfAw2n7dKJvtz3TsNB_prxL5ekB4sjL8KnvBGNXN2QCB9AikYeBqBtaa2cKJ1nn1DUK-ix5fLj_bG5bImB4HDx75oGdpPeR2qfitXApcX8XpQBRaElqKI-7sO6FE0Cb1pbzQNcYapxvLCm-ugrdgAO9tg=w834-h625-no?authuser=0

Edited by FossilRPalace
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

 

Where do your photos come from ? The links are broken !
 
Coco
  • I Agree 1

----------------------
OUTIL POUR MESURER VOS FOSSILES : ici

Ma bibliothèque PDF 1 (Poissons et sélaciens récents & fossiles) : ici
Ma bibliothèque PDF 2 (Animaux vivants - sans poissons ni sélaciens) : ici
Mâchoires sélaciennes récentes : ici
Hétérodontiques et sélaciens : ici
Oeufs sélaciens récents : ici
Otolithes de poissons récents ! ici

Un Greg...

Badges-IPFOTH.jpg.f4a8635cda47a3cc506743a8aabce700.jpg Badges-MOTM.jpg.461001e1a9db5dc29ca1c07a041a1a86.jpg

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

:DittoSign:

 

I don’t see any pictures either. :( 

Edited by FossilNerd

The good thing about science is that it's true whether or not you believe in it.  -Neil deGrasse Tyson

 

Everyone you will ever meet knows something you don't. -Bill Nye (The Science Guy)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@FossilRPalace

Please re-post the photos directly to the Forum.

    Tim    -  VETERAN SHALE SPLITTER

   MOTM.png.61350469b02f439fd4d5d77c2c69da85.png      PaleoPartner.png.30c01982e09b0cc0b7d9d6a7a21f56c6.png.a600039856933851eeea617ca3f2d15f.png     Postmaster1.jpg.900efa599049929531fa81981f028e24.jpg    VFOTM.png.f1b09c78bf88298b009b0da14ef44cf0.png  VFOTM  --- APRIL - 2015  

__________________________________________________
"In every walk with nature one receives far more than he seeks."

John Muir ~ ~ ~ ~   ><))))( *>  About Me      

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...