Unidentified Devonian Fish Tooth

Jeff, I know you know your paleontology, but that tooth looks suspiciously like the internal part of a horn coral ?

12 minutes ago, Stingray said:

Jeff, I know you know your paleontology, but that tooth looks suspiciously like the internal part of a horn coral ?

It's not. It is a fish tooth. The Catskill Formation where we collected these is very well known for them.

 brother I figured as much. Like I prefaced it with Jeff knows his stuff I was pointing out the similarities between the two. Tooth it is 

1 minute ago, Stingray said:

 brother I figured as much. Like I prefaced it with Jeff knows his stuff I was pointing out the similarities between the two. Tooth it is 

Out of curiosity, what does the broken end of yours look like?

On these fish teeth, you can see the enamel sheath where they break.

Looks like this same all the way