Jump to content

Ankylosaurus magniventris tooth or Thescelosaurus?


Compy

Recommended Posts

Hi all,

 

with Covid making it impossible to attend any shows here last year I was able to visit the Munich Show last weekend.


Among others I’ve bought this tooth.

Ive learned from you guys not to trust the ID done by the seller so after reading some posts here I doubt that the tooth is a ankylosaurus magniventris. To me it looks more like a Thescelosaurus.

Am I correct with this opinion?


Details provided by the seller:

Hell Creek Formation 

North West South Dakota

 

Thanks in advance for your expertise!

8F7AFCD3-2312-4829-BF0D-E0C293D16488.jpeg

7629217C-5F26-4DD9-91F7-8E6D0481C162.jpeg

DC8A0CF9-0A94-4D3D-AE8A-092CE0587789.jpeg

  • Enjoyed 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I initially thought it was a Nodosaur tooth and definitively not a Thescelosaurus but the tooth appears to have a strong center ridge and shelf which would say Anky.    It appears to have a damaged bulbous platform shown by an arrow in the photo below.   So check your specimen the photos are a bit darker than I would like.   A nodosaur crown would be missing the ridge and have a pocket in its place see photo

Thescelosaurus denticles would not be as strong with no lateral platform.

post-10935-0-01475200-1440178742.thumb.jpg.5cccedf534bcf2729a06a3a30bfae61e.jpg.31d0ca89eb6e24d6eda0fb8ce15c20e9.jpg

Nodosaurid

post-10935-0-51559100-1440179641.thumb.jpg.1f553825f022cb47b59a22c2cf61c851.jpg.924b7935567ba5dca54f4d214dbe2ffc.jpg

 

  • Enjoyed 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you @Troodon
and @Runner64

 

I tried to take some better pictures because i wasnt quite sure about the center ridge and the bulbous platform, which let me lean towards nodosaurid.

But I think given the not that perfect state of preservation I think I can see the center ridge and some faint bulb too...

 

P.S. Please excuse me not being able to produce such nice macro pictures for I don't have a decent camera...

20211026_082353.jpg

20211026_082450.jpg

20211026_082330_001.jpg

20211026_082311.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Much better photo, I see why you are saying that but I still think Its Anky.   There  is center ridge not very pronounced and the damage to the bulbous area does not help.  A Nodosaur face is typically more of a pocket and I don't see that.

 

Just an FYI, I've also attached an illustration of the different morphs of Thescelosaurus and you can see how fine the denticles are on the ridge.

 

20211026_082353.thumb.jpg.9c502e55dacec1f3cf06bb84633c4df4.jpg.a3deab630182549f8dba33d08709a1d3.jpg20211026_082353.thumb.jpg.9c502e55dacec1f3cf06bb84633c4df41.jpg.a2aedbb1241a0ceb9397515faf200299.jpg

post-10935-0-88056700-1459189152.jpg.2e9aba23383b35493872fb68548f3c18.jpg

 

 

BTY for future posts try to post closeup images and ones facing in the direction shown in my images.  Hard to diagnose teeth that are upside down.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@TroodonThank you very much. I see your points. Just couldn’t believe that the seller was correct and I was able to get my hands on a tooth of this species. :-)

 

@Runner64Thank you got your help too! 
 

Sorry for the bad pictures, next time I will remember to upload them properly facing upwards.

 

I really appreciate your knowledge and help!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

33 minutes ago, Compy said:

.Just couldn’t believe that the seller was correct

Hey even a blind squirrel finds a nut :)

  • Enjoyed 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...